New York-style pizza shopMadison$$$$
Pinky Ring Pizza
New York-style pies in a former Sir Pizza in Madison. If it has ricotta, order it, and come at lunch for the two-slice special.
#7 in Pizza
What to get
- Madtown (meatballs sliced like pepperoni, ricotta, peppers)
- New Haven Red
- Madison Hot Pickle (white sauce, smoked provolone, pickles)
- Fig & Pig
When to go
Lunch for the two-slice special at the counter (Infatuation).
Insider tip
In a former Sir Pizza in a Madison strip mall; rule of thumb: if it has ricotta, get it (Infatuation). 18-inch pies (Eater).
Heads up
A drive from downtown; hours not posted on the site.
Find it
- Phone
- (615) 481-7693
- Website
- pinkyringpizza.com
- Reservations
- walk-in only
Recognition
Checked Oct. 1, 2026. Ratings are a snapshot from Google and Yelp; ranks are ours (how we rank). Something out of date? Tell us.
Eat & Drink
More in Pizza
-
#1Japanese-style pizza · East Nashville
Sho Pizza Bar
Personal pizzas with Japanese toppings in Inglewood, from a kitchen with a Michelin Bib Gourmand.
-
#2New York-style pizza · East Nashville
Five Points Pizza
New York-style pies and slices in East Nashville's Five Points, plus shops in West Nashville and the Gulch.
-
#3Sicilian pizza · The Gulch
St. Vito Focacceria
Thick, crisp-edged Sicilian sfincione and pastas, with a Michelin Bib Gourmand.
-
#5Italian-Southern restaurant · Germantown
City House
Italian-Southern cooking in Germantown from Tandy Wilson, the first Nashville chef to win a James Beard Award. Get the belly ham pizza with an egg.
-
#6Chicago tavern-style pizza · Wedgewood-Houston
Dicey's Pizza & Tavern
Party-cut Chicago tavern pies in Wedgewood-Houston, with a back patio for kids. The Scene named its pepperoni a Nashville classic.
-
#8New York-style pizza · West Nashville
NY Pie
A tiny Charlotte Pike slice shop run by Greg Meyer, who learned in New York and New Jersey pizzerias. Try the grandma or the Sicilian.
The NashvilleTN Insider · 10K+ readers
The best of Nashville, in your inbox.
The shows worth buying tickets for, what just opened, where happy hour is good right now, the weekend plan, and a heads-up before we go live.